Shower Curtains vs. Shower Doors: Weighing the Pros and Cons

Are you unsure whether to choose a shower curtain or a shower door for your bathroom renovation? This comprehensive guide compares the pros and cons of each option to help you make an informed decision. Discover the affordability and versatility of shower curtains, along with the easy maintenance, durability, and modern aesthetic of glass shower doors. Consider factors like cost, ease of cleaning, durability, aesthetics, and home value to find the perfect solution for your bathroom.

Are you in the midst of a bathroom renovation and finding it difficult to choose between a shower curtain and a shower door? It's a common dilemma, but fear not! We're here to help you make an informed decision that will bring joy to your bathroom for years to come.

Let's dive into the pros and cons of both shower enclosures to make your choice a little easier:

Shower Curtains

Bathroom with a shower curtain


Affordable: Shower curtains are budget-friendly, with some options costing as little as $20. Plus, they offer the flexibility to change up your bathroom's look easily.

If you're on a tight budget, consider pairing it with a curved shower rod to create extra shower space and keep water inside, preventing any potential safety hazards.


Frequent Replacement: Shower curtains require regular washing and replacement due to the accumulation of humidity and lack of ventilation. This can result in higher long-term costs.

Not Durable: Shower curtains don't stand the test of time, typically needing replacement every few months unless you're diligent about drying them off after each use. Cloth curtains are more prone to collecting soap scum, and they may trap bacteria more than shower doors.

Shower Doors

Bathroom with a modern shower door


Easy to Clean: Glass shower doors are a fantastic choice for busy households due to their easy-to-clean and maintainable nature, a shower door can keep your bathroom looking tidy. Unlike shower curtains, shower doors dry quickly.

Ideal for Tricky Spaces: If your bathroom is in an awkwardly-shaped area like an alcove or a converted attic nook, shower doors are the best option. They can accommodate nonstandard heights, recesses, and angles, providing you with a long-lasting, splash-proof solution (although customization might come at an additional cost).

Durable: Glass shower doors are less likely to suffer damage or wear and tear, making them ideal for bathrooms with high traffic. With proper maintenance, they can last up to 30 years.


Cost: Shower doors can be more expensive. Opting for a frameless design can increase the cost further. Additionally, if you have a uniquely-shaped bathroom, you might need to pay extra for a customized shower door.

Modern Aesthetic: Nothing exudes elegance like a glass shower door. It provides a sleek and modern aesthetic, dramatically transforming your bathroom's look and feel. It opens up space and adds a minimalist touch, enhancing your existing interior design elements.

Water Containment: Shower doors create a tight seal, preventing water from escaping the shower area. No more stepping out of the shower only to find a puddle on the floor! Sliding shower doors are particularly suitable for space-constrained bathrooms since they don't pivot outward.

Glass shower door with handle

Do Shower Doors Add Value?

Shower with a half door

Installing a shower door during a bathroom remodel adds both style and functionality, ultimately increasing the resale value of your home. Bathroom renovations have a high return on investment and can pay for themselves over time.

If you decide to go with a shower curtain, consider complementing it with a curved shower rod to maximize your shower area. This will not only enlarge your space but also keep the wet and sticky curtain away from your body, providing enhanced comfort.

As you embark on your bathroom renovation journey, make sure to choose the best bathroom features that suit your needs and preferences. Happy renovating!